Nadia Whitlock
A-8586Their final recommendation: “Profit fell because store rent rose ~20% after lease renewals” · revised after Maya's challenge
Interview decision
Saving stops the review timer. A person decides; nothing is sent to the candidate automatically.
Review timer
0:00
started when you opened this review
Digest · three moments, each linked to its time in the log
Rubric · 4 dimensions · 1–10 · click for anchors and evidence
Scores backed by Keewano evidence this candidate company baseline (avg of 2 sample employees) applicant median (n = 21)Evidence from Keewano
Evidence from Keewano
Evidence from Keewano
Evidence from Keewano
Review aid (demo rubric), not a hiring decision · scored by claude-opus-5 from the action log
Beside sample employees · same case
Sample employees| Nadia Whitlock | Associate ConsultantSample employee · 2nd year | Engagement ManagerSample employee · Manager | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Problem definition | 2 | 9 | 9 |
| Communication | 2 | 9 | 8 |
| AI verification | 2 | 9 | 9 |
| Adaptation | 3 | 9 | 9 |
| Checked the AI's claim | no | yes | yes |
| Asked the client finance analyst | no | yes | yes |
| Revised after the challenge | yes | yes | yes |
| Time on the case | 30m 00s | 33m 20s | 21m 40s |
Two reference runs of the same case by sample employees, shown for context. Not a benchmark: no percentiles or predictions from two samples.
Evidence · open the exact exchange behind each claim
Messaged Helen Ward
“Yes, it's rent: rents went up about 20%.” · no new fact in the reply
#5
From app event log
Relied on the AI without checking
AI: “Summary of the preliminary findings: the main controllable driver is store rent, which ro…” · no check against the docs or the analyst before the final.
#3
From app event log
Revised after Maya's challenge
Before: “Profit fell because store rent rose ~20% after lease renewals” → After: “Profit fell because store rent rose ~20% after lease renewals”
#7 · #8 · #9
From app event log
Mid-point check-in
Never sent the required check-in to the manager.
Missing from the record: nothing to open.